David Buceta
All workGet in touch
← All work
UX case study · Five Below

Five Below Homepage

The company was changing from Magento 1 to Magento 2 giving us the opportunity to recreate the entire online customer experience.

Three phone wireframes showing the structure of the redesigned homepage
My role
Lead Product Designer
Timeline
6 months
Team
3 Senior Leaders
1 Graphic Designer
1 Copy Writer
2 Developers
Tools
Figma Photoshop HTML + CSS JIRA Whiteboards + Coffee
Deliverables
Web + mobile UI Design system guidelines Homepage flow guidance ADA compliance
88.2%
engagement rate on the redesigned homepage, February 24 to March 2, 2026
Jump to Define Research Ideate Prototype Final result
01

Define

The problem

Five Below was still using Magento 1 which was being sunset by Adobe. For security reasons we needed to quickly move the site to Magento 2.

Goals

Redefine the structure of the entire site during this transition period. Starting with the homepage define the positioning of all the basic elements for a purposeful flow. This would allow for fast and consistent structure on future design updates. Allowing for style changes later on that would be easy to orchestrate.

02

Research

List of elements

We determined what elements we currently have on site and what could be added on. We did not hold back on ideas and let them all come out onto the whiteboard. These would later be prioritized based on the need vs difficulty to build within our timeline.

Whiteboard covered in a handwritten list of homepage elements and priorities

Interviews

We interviewed people from various backgrounds to understand their needs for a website. Ranging from using the mobile experience to pre-shop before going to a store, to desktop only users buying for their kids. Every experience and situation needed careful consideration.

Competitor analysis

Reviewing many sites across all genres allows for a deeper understanding of what online flows look like. This gives a birds eye view of what age groups and demographics are looking for in each category.

A collage of competitor homepage screenshots across many retail categories

Data visualization

We further broke down what each section of the competitors were doing on their sites and how it would relate to Five Below. This really came together with a visualization of the job accomplished by each section with a color coded chart. Senior Leadership was easily able to digest this information quickly allowing them to supply proper feedback.

Target audience

Teens and tweens are the focus for Five Below as a company tent pole. The website is a different audience as the customer is typically an older adult buying for their child or grandchild.

Color-coded chart breaking down the job of each competitor homepage section
03

Ideate

Sketches from the room

We gathered all data onto sticky notes and began working to find patterns and connections in all of our research. What came out of this was a brainstorming session that was a joy to walk into everyday.

Six whiteboard sketches of homepage layouts and flows

Homepage flow

Components pulled from the competitor analysis matched up with the learning from our interviews determined what modules would be best in position on the site. Pairing them with the screengrabs along with a wireframe mockup showing them in position helped the senior leadership visualize the homepage coming together.

04

Prototype

High fidelity prototyping

Designing the image assets within the design allowed for everyone to get their hands on a working model of the homepage. With all the branding and color involved you can really see the details of the work come together. The customer may only see fun graphics and elements without realizing the carefully constructed framework the page is built upon. Moving the customer along on a journey that is impactful and feels as natural as walking down the aisle of the store itself.

High fidelity homepage prototype shown on three phones
05

Final result

Our design process, driven by extensive research and user feedback, led to the creation of an intuitive and user-friendly homepage for all customers. Both returning and first time shoppers will enjoy the experience of being on the Five Below site.

Key features such as the timing of product placement on site along with 'find a store' options allow all users to feel completely in control of the experience. Giving the user options to control how they interact with a site brings longer retention along with increased engagement rate.

All of this work delivered an increased engagement rate hitting over 88%.

Analytics report: homepage engagement rate of 88.2% for February 24 to March 2, 2026, and the daily engagement trend
Next project
Five Below UX / UI creation
View case study →

Let's make something good.

Open to senior digital and graphic design roles and projects. Email is the fastest way to reach me.

contact@davidbuceta.com LinkedIn
David Buceta, Senior Graphic & Digital Designer